Footy commentators are divided over whether or not a controversial penalty was warranted throughout Melbourne’s thrilling win over Souths.
Commentators have questioned a controversial name that went Souths’ approach late in Melbourne’s thrilling win over the Bunnies on Thursday evening.
Trailing 14-8 with just some minutes remaining, Rabbitohs followers thought their facet had bottled a possible strive when centre Campbell Graham knocked on as they created an overlap on the precise edge.
Stream each sport of each spherical of the 2022 NRL Telstra Premiership Season Live & Ad-Break Free In Play on Kayo. New to Kayo? Try 14-Days Free Now >
But Souths challenged the decision and the Bunker discovered Melbourne had tackled Cameron Murray off the ball within the lead-up to the knock-on and awarded a penalty to the visiting facet.
Murray was operating an outside-in line however ended up getting used a decoy when a cross went behind him to a different teammate. Trent Loiero nonetheless tackled the Souths skipper and he tumbled backwards, prompting the Bunker to award a penalty as a result of Murray was taken out with out the ball.
“He knows he was hit without the ball,” Fox League commentator Andrew Voss mentioned as some questioned what the problem was for given Graham’s knock-on seemed clear reduce.
Graham scored from the ensuing set of six to scale back the deficit to 2 factors, earlier than Latrell Mitchell kicked a surprising long-range two-point subject purpose to ship the conflict into golden level further time.
That’s the place the comeback ended although, as Ryan Papenhuyzen kicked a subject purpose to assert victory for the Storm.
Not everybody was satisfied Murray deserved a penalty within the dying levels. NRL legend Andrew Johns advised Nine: “He (Loiero) has to set himself to tackle. He can’t pull out there. He’s got his feet positioned to tackle.”
Storm legend Cameron Smith added: “And the thing is if (Rabbitohs halfback Lachlan) Ilias plays short to Cam Murray, a defender needs to be prepared to make contact. It’s the fabric of our game.”
Sports reporter Michael Chammas tweeted: “Unfair for the Storm. That ruling will encourage coaches to teach their players to fall backwards if a decoy player (Cam Murray in this instance) makes contact with them. That’s not what we want.”
Originally printed as Obstruction rule nonetheless inflicting complications within the NRL